The most-asked question about closed approach: are there really no scars? Honest discussion of external vs internal scarring, the columellar scar in open rhinoplasty, and scar care protocols for both approaches.
Closed approach has no external nasal scars — incisions are entirely inside the nostrils. Internal incisions exist but are invisible externally and rarely cause functional issues. Open approach has a small columellar scar (3-4mm) that typically fades to near-invisibility at conversational distance within 6-12 months. Patient anatomy, skin type, and scar care protocol affect final scar quality.
Open rhinoplasty uses a small inverted-V or stair-step incision across the columella (the strip of skin between the nostrils). The incision is approximately 3-4mm across.
The scar is visible:
The scar is typically not visible:
Most columellar scars heal well. Less optimal scars are associated with:
Even in the best columellar scars healing optimally, the scar exists. Patients can see it in mirror inspection. The concept of "no scar at all" is appealing in itself, regardless of how invisible the alternative scar might become.
Some patients place strong personal value on having no external mark of surgery — both for their own daily mirror inspection and for the principle of preserving anatomical naturalness. This is a valid personal value, not anatomical superiority.
Closed rhinoplasty has internal scarring (inside the nostrils) where the incisions are made. This is invisible externally but worth understanding:
Internal incisions in closed rhinoplasty rarely cause functional problems. Concerns include:
If the procedure includes alar base reduction (narrowing wide nostrils), incisions are placed at the alar base — at the natural crease where the nostril meets the cheek. These are external incisions (not internal) but heal as fine lines hidden in the natural anatomical crease.
Osteotomies (controlled bone cuts to narrow the nasal pyramid) can be performed:
Modern piezo rhinoplasty technique can perform osteotomies with reduced soft tissue trauma. While not directly affecting scarring, the gentler bone cutting reduces post-op bruising and swelling — making the immediate post-op period easier.
Whether closed or open approach, scar care matters for any incision (internal or external):
No external scars on the nose — closed approach uses incisions entirely inside the nostrils. Internal incisions exist but are invisible externally and rarely cause functional issues. If alar base reduction is included (for narrowing wide nostrils), small incisions at the alar base are external but heal as fine lines hidden in the natural crease. Percutaneous osteotomies (if used) leave tiny scars that are typically near-invisible by 6 months.
Most columellar scars heal to fine lines that are: visible up close in mirror inspection (always), visible in macro photography of the columella, and not visible at normal conversational distance or in standard photography. Approximately 95% of columellar scars heal well. Patients with keloid tendency, darker skin types, or healing complications may have more visible scars.
Both statements are true depending on perspective. Externally — closed rhinoplasty has no visible scars (this is what 'scarless rhinoplasty' refers to). Internally — closed approach uses incisions inside the nostrils that exist as small lines after healing, but are invisible externally and rarely cause issues. The 'invisible scars' marketing refers to external appearance; the internal scars are clinically minimal.
Only if your anatomy and goals allow it. Closed approach is appropriate for the majority of primary rhinoplasty cases when surgeon expertise is sufficient. If your case requires complex revision, major grafting, or severe asymmetry correction, open approach may produce a better functional and aesthetic result — and the columellar scar typically heals well. Discuss with your surgeon what your specific case actually needs, not just what you prefer.
External incisions: initial healing 1-2 weeks, scar maturation 6-12 months, final appearance by 12-18 months. Internal incisions: healing 2-3 weeks, no further long-term changes. Optimal scar care during this period (silicone gel for external, saline rinses for internal, sun protection for both) significantly affects final scar quality. Patient compliance with scar care protocol is the most controllable factor in scar outcome.
Direct surgeon access · No agency layer · Personalised technique recommendation
WhatsApp Dr. Erdal →